Yellow, green and orange pawns stand on the island of Tortuga on a teal sea map, beside gold treasure chests and two wooden pirate ships

Tortuga 1667: Plan a Game Night for a Bigger Group

Every pirate at the table swears they are on your side. At least one of them is lying. That is the fun of Tortuga 1667, a hidden-role pirate board game from Facade Games for two to nine players, ages 14 and up, with a listed play time of 20 to 40 minutes.

Players secretly side with the British or the French. Two pirate crews steal gold from a Spanish galleon, stage mutinies and maroon rivals on the island of Tortuga. When the Spanish Armada card turns up, the team with more treasure wins.

The big takeaway? This game is built for a crowd. Invite at least five people, and aim for an odd number if you can.

Tortuga 1667 with five players

Ric White of One Board Family recommends the game for big groups. He says it “plays best with at least five players,” because smaller games lose the teamwork. Read his full Tortuga 1667 review.

Five players split into two British pirates, two French pirates and one Dutch pirate. The Dutch player sails alone and wins only if the treasure ends in a tie, so they quietly prop up whichever side is losing.

Overhead view of a Tortuga 1667 sea map on a red table with five pawns on two ships, a row of five face-down event cards and a vote card
A five-player game, with the row of face-down event cards below the map. Courtesy of No Rolls Barred, from the video “Let’s Play TORTUGA 1667 | Board Game Club.”

Turns come back around faster, too. In the five-player game on the No Rolls Barred channel, the table was still guessing who held the Dutch card in the closing minutes.

Tortuga 1667 with nine players

Nine is the maximum: four British, four French and one Dutch. The hosts of The Game Garage channel often play at that size, and they say “it plays the best at nine players or seven players.” The lone Dutch pirate creates huge uncertainty, and the final turns bring big reveals.

Here’s the catch: downtime. With nine people, they point out, it takes a long time for your turn to come back. Their fix is simple. If someone can’t decide, they should just peek at two event cards and pass play along.

The map is small, too. Seat everyone close enough to see it.

A Tortuga 1667 box shaped like an old leather book stands behind a sea map, colorful pawns, gold treasure chests and stacks of cards on a wooden table
The book-style box, the roll-up map, the pawns, the gold treasure and the card decks. Courtesy of Facade Games.

Teach it fast

Facade Games’ own rules video runs under five minutes, so the whole table can learn the basics in one short sitting. Give everyone a player card, a secret loyalty card and three vote cards. For a first game, Facade says to leave out the starred event cards.

On your turn, you take one action. Anyone can peek at two event cards, reveal one, or make another player reveal one. Your spot on a ship unlocks more:

  • Captain. Calls an attack on the Spanish galleon.
  • First mate. Calls a mutiny against the captain.
  • Cabin boy. Moves treasure from one hold to the other.

White warns that several rules run at once, so some new players will simply follow their teammates’ advice. Everyone still has a part to play.

Dutch, French and British loyalty cards fanned on a wooden table beside a stack of vote cards showing a ship wheel, flags and a cannon
Secret loyalty cards set your team. Vote cards decide attacks, mutinies and brawls. Courtesy of Facade Games.

How long do the secrets last?

Not as long as you might think. In White’s games, “our identities become evident after three or four rounds.” After that, the plotting gets loud.

You don’t have to be a great liar, either. Facade notes that some players win by bluffing to the very end, while others tell the truth all game and let the event cards do the work.

Small details

White also praises the components: a box styled like an old book with a magnetic lid, and a neoprene map that rolls up without wrinkles. With an even number of players, there is no Dutch card.

If your crew wants more pirate fun, our Skull King guide covers a trick-taking card game for up to eight.

Watch: Tortuga 1667 at the table

Facade Games explains the rules in under five minutes.

No Rolls Barred plays a full five-player game.

The Game Garage explains why the game shines at seven or nine players.

More from Hobbies

View all